Tolerate zlib deflation with window size < 32Kb

Git currently reports loose objects as 'corrupt' if they've been
deflated using a window size less than 32Kb, because the
experimental_loose_object() function doesn't recognise the header
byte as a zlib header. This patch makes the function tolerant of
all valid window sizes (15-bit to 8-bit) - but doesn't sacrifice
it's accuracy in distingushing the standard loose-object format
from the experimental (now abandoned) format.

On memory constrained systems zlib may use a much smaller window
size - working on Agit, I found that Android uses a 4KB window;
giving a header byte of 0x48, not 0x78. Consequently all loose
objects generated appear 'corrupt', which is why Agit is a read-only
Git client at this time - I don't want my client to generate Git
repos that other clients treat as broken :(

This patch makes Git tolerant of different deflate settings - it
might appear that it changes experimental_loose_object() to the point
where it could incorrectly identify the experimental format as the
standard one, but the two criteria (bitmask & checksum) can only
give a false result for an experimental object where both of the
following are true:

1) object size is exactly 8 bytes when uncompressed (bitmask)
2) [single-byte in-pack git type&size header] * 256
   + [1st byte of the following zlib header] % 31 = 0 (checksum)

As it happens, for all possible combinations of valid object type
(1-4) and window bits (0-7), the only time when the checksum will be
divisible by 31 is for 0x1838 - ie object type *1*, a Commit - which,
due the fields all Commit objects must contain, could never be as
small as 8 bytes in size.

Given this, the combination of the two criteria (bitmask & checksum)
always correctly determines the buffer format, and is more tolerant
than the previous version.

The alternative to this patch is simply removing support for the
experimental format, which I am also totally cool with.

References:

Android uses a 4KB window for deflation:
http://android.git.kernel.org/?p=platform/libcore.git;a=blob;f=luni/src/main/native/java_util_zip_Deflater.cpp;h=c0b2feff196e63a7b85d97cf9ae5bb2583409c28;hb=refs/heads/gingerbread#l53

Code snippet searching for false positives with the zlib checksum:
https://gist.github.com/1118177

Signed-off-by: Roberto Tyley <roberto.tyley@guardian.co.uk>
Signed-off-by: Junio C Hamano <gitster@pobox.com>

1 files changed, 26 insertions, 6 deletions

diff --git a/sha1_file.c b/sha1_file.c
index 697f4a43c..475d215c1 100644
--- a/sha1_file.c
+++ b/sha1_file.c
@@ -1217,14 +1217,34 @@ static int experimental_loose_object(unsigned char *map)
 	unsigned int word;
 
 	/*
-	 * Is it a zlib-compressed buffer? If so, the first byte
-	 * must be 0x78 (15-bit window size, deflated), and the
-	 * first 16-bit word is evenly divisible by 31. If so,
-	 * we are looking at the official format, not the experimental
-	 * one.
+	 * We must determine if the buffer contains the standard
+	 * zlib-deflated stream or the experimental format based
+	 * on the in-pack object format. Compare the header byte
+	 * for each format:
+	 *
+	 * RFC1950 zlib w/ deflate : 0www1000 : 0 <= www <= 7
+	 * Experimental pack-based : Stttssss : ttt = 1,2,3,4
+	 *
+	 * If bit 7 is clear and bits 0-3 equal 8, the buffer MUST be
+	 * in standard loose-object format, UNLESS it is a Git-pack
+	 * format object *exactly* 8 bytes in size when inflated.
+	 *
+	 * However, RFC1950 also specifies that the 1st 16-bit word
+	 * must be divisible by 31 - this checksum tells us our buffer
+	 * is in the standard format, giving a false positive only if
+	 * the 1st word of the Git-pack format object happens to be
+	 * divisible by 31, ie:
+	 *      ((byte0 * 256) + byte1) % 31 = 0
+	 *   =>        0ttt10000www1000 % 31 = 0
+	 *
+	 * As it happens, this case can only arise for www=3 & ttt=1
+	 * - ie, a Commit object, which would have to be 8 bytes in
+	 * size. As no Commit can be that small, we find that the
+	 * combination of these two criteria (bitmask & checksum)
+	 * can always correctly determine the buffer format.
 	 */
 	word = (map[0] << 8) + map[1];
-	if (map[0] == 0x78 && !(word % 31))
+	if ((map[0] & 0x8F) == 0x08 && !(word % 31))
 		return 0;
 	else
 		return 1;