Merge branch 'kb/full-history-compute-treesame-carefully-2'

Major update to the revision traversal logic to improve culling of
irrelevant parents while traversing a mergy history.

* kb/full-history-compute-treesame-carefully-2:
  revision.c: make default history consider bottom commits
  revision.c: don't show all merges for --parents
  revision.c: discount side branches when computing TREESAME
  revision.c: add BOTTOM flag for commits
  simplify-merges: drop merge from irrelevant side branch
  simplify-merges: never remove all TREESAME parents
  t6012: update test for tweaked full-history traversal
  revision.c: Make --full-history consider more merges
  Documentation: avoid "uninteresting"
  rev-list-options.txt: correct TREESAME for P
  t6111: add parents to tests
  t6111: allow checking the parents as well
  t6111: new TREESAME test set
  t6019: test file dropped in -s ours merge
  decorate.c: compact table when growing

7 files changed, 750 insertions, 91 deletions

diff --git a/Documentation/rev-list-options.txt b/Documentation/rev-list-options.txt
index 3bdbf5e85..b462f17f6 100644
--- a/Documentation/rev-list-options.txt
+++ b/Documentation/rev-list-options.txt
@@ -271,8 +271,8 @@ See also linkgit:git-reflog[1].
 
 --boundary::
 
-	Output uninteresting commits at the boundary, which are usually
-	not shown.
+	Output excluded boundary commits. Boundary commits are
+	prefixed with `-`.
 
 --
 
@@ -342,13 +342,13 @@ In the following, we will always refer to the same example history to
 illustrate the differences between simplification settings.  We assume
 that you are filtering for a file `foo` in this commit graph:
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
-	  .-A---M---N---O---P
-	 /     /   /   /   /
-	I     B   C   D   E
-	 \   /   /   /   /
-	  `-------------'
+	  .-A---M---N---O---P---Q
+	 /     /   /   /   /   /
+	I     B   C   D   E   Y
+	 \   /   /   /   /   /
+	  `-------------'   X
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
-The horizontal line of history A---P is taken to be the first parent of
+The horizontal line of history A---Q is taken to be the first parent of
 each merge.  The commits are:
 
 * `I` is the initial commit, in which `foo` exists with contents
@@ -367,8 +367,11 @@ each merge.  The commits are:
   `N` and `D` to "foobarbaz"; i.e., it is not TREESAME to any parent.
 
 * `E` changes `quux` to "xyzzy", and its merge `P` combines the
-  strings to "quux xyzzy".  Despite appearing interesting, `P` is
-  TREESAME to all parents.
+  strings to "quux xyzzy".  `P` is TREESAME to `O`, but not to `E`.
+
+* `X` is an indpendent root commit that added a new file `side`, and `Y`
+  modified it. `Y` is TREESAME to `X`. Its merge `Q` added `side` to `P`, and
+  `Q` is TREESAME to `P`, but not to `Y`.
 
 'rev-list' walks backwards through history, including or excluding
 commits based on whether '\--full-history' and/or parent rewriting
@@ -410,10 +413,10 @@ parent lines.
 	the example, we get
 +
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
-	I  A  B  N  D  O
+	I  A  B  N  D  O  P  Q
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
 +
-`P` and `M` were excluded because they are TREESAME to a parent.  `E`,
+`M` was excluded because it is TREESAME to both parents.  `E`,
 `C` and `B` were all walked, but only `B` was !TREESAME, so the others
 do not appear.
 +
@@ -431,7 +434,7 @@ Along each parent, prune away commits that are not included
 themselves.  This results in
 +
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
-	  .-A---M---N---O---P
+	  .-A---M---N---O---P---Q
 	 /     /   /   /   /
 	I     B   /   D   /
 	 \   /   /   /   /
@@ -441,7 +444,7 @@ themselves.  This results in
 Compare to '\--full-history' without rewriting above.  Note that `E`
 was pruned away because it is TREESAME, but the parent list of P was
 rewritten to contain `E`'s parent `I`.  The same happened for `C` and
-`N`.  Note also that `P` was included despite being TREESAME.
+`N`, and `X`, `Y` and `Q`.
 
 In addition to the above settings, you can change whether TREESAME
 affects inclusion:
@@ -471,8 +474,9 @@ history according to the following rules:
 * Set `C'` to `C`.
 +
 * Replace each parent `P` of `C'` with its simplification `P'`.  In
-  the process, drop parents that are ancestors of other parents, and
-  remove duplicates.
+  the process, drop parents that are ancestors of other parents or that are
+  root commits TREESAME to an empty tree, and remove duplicates, but take care
+  to never drop all parents that we are TREESAME to.
 +
 * If after this parent rewriting, `C'` is a root or merge commit (has
   zero or >1 parents), a boundary commit, or !TREESAME, it remains.
@@ -490,7 +494,7 @@ The effect of this is best shown by way of comparing to
 	  `---------'
 -----------------------------------------------------------------------
 +
-Note the major differences in `N` and `P` over '--full-history':
+Note the major differences in `N`, `P` and `Q` over '--full-history':
 +
 --
 * `N`'s parent list had `I` removed, because it is an ancestor of the
@@ -498,6 +502,10 @@ Note the major differences in `N` and `P` over '--full-history':
 +
 * `P`'s parent list similarly had `I` removed.  `P` was then
   removed completely, because it had one parent and is TREESAME.
++
+* `Q`'s parent list had `Y` simplified to `X`. `X` was then removed, because it
+  was a TREESAME root. `Q` was then removed completely, because it had one
+  parent and is TREESAME.
 --
 
 Finally, there is a fifth simplification mode available:
diff --git a/decorate.c b/decorate.c
index 2f8a63e38..7cb5d29a8 100644
--- a/decorate.c
+++ b/decorate.c
@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ static void grow_decoration(struct decoration *n)
 		const struct object *base = old_hash[i].base;
 		void *decoration = old_hash[i].decoration;
 
-		if (!base)
+		if (!decoration)
 			continue;
 		insert_decoration(n, base, decoration);
 	}
diff --git a/revision.c b/revision.c
index 518cd0869..9318b7d76 100644
--- a/revision.c
+++ b/revision.c
@@ -334,6 +334,80 @@ static int everybody_uninteresting(struct commit_list *orig)
 }
 
 /*
+ * A definition of "relevant" commit that we can use to simplify limited graphs
+ * by eliminating side branches.
+ *
+ * A "relevant" commit is one that is !UNINTERESTING (ie we are including it
+ * in our list), or that is a specified BOTTOM commit. Then after computing
+ * a limited list, during processing we can generally ignore boundary merges
+ * coming from outside the graph, (ie from irrelevant parents), and treat
+ * those merges as if they were single-parent. TREESAME is defined to consider
+ * only relevant parents, if any. If we are TREESAME to our on-graph parents,
+ * we don't care if we were !TREESAME to non-graph parents.
+ *
+ * Treating bottom commits as relevant ensures that a limited graph's
+ * connection to the actual bottom commit is not viewed as a side branch, but
+ * treated as part of the graph. For example:
+ *
+ *   ....Z...A---X---o---o---B
+ *        .     /
+ *         W---Y
+ *
+ * When computing "A..B", the A-X connection is at least as important as
+ * Y-X, despite A being flagged UNINTERESTING.
+ *
+ * And when computing --ancestry-path "A..B", the A-X connection is more
+ * important than Y-X, despite both A and Y being flagged UNINTERESTING.
+ */
+static inline int relevant_commit(struct commit *commit)
+{
+	return (commit->object.flags & (UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM)) != UNINTERESTING;
+}
+
+/*
+ * Return a single relevant commit from a parent list. If we are a TREESAME
+ * commit, and this selects one of our parents, then we can safely simplify to
+ * that parent.
+ */
+static struct commit *one_relevant_parent(const struct rev_info *revs,
+					  struct commit_list *orig)
+{
+	struct commit_list *list = orig;
+	struct commit *relevant = NULL;
+
+	if (!orig)
+		return NULL;
+
+	/*
+	 * For 1-parent commits, or if first-parent-only, then return that
+	 * first parent (even if not "relevant" by the above definition).
+	 * TREESAME will have been set purely on that parent.
+	 */
+	if (revs->first_parent_only || !orig->next)
+		return orig->item;
+
+	/*
+	 * For multi-parent commits, identify a sole relevant parent, if any.
+	 * If we have only one relevant parent, then TREESAME will be set purely
+	 * with regard to that parent, and we can simplify accordingly.
+	 *
+	 * If we have more than one relevant parent, or no relevant parents
+	 * (and multiple irrelevant ones), then we can't select a parent here
+	 * and return NULL.
+	 */
+	while (list) {
+		struct commit *commit = list->item;
+		list = list->next;
+		if (relevant_commit(commit)) {
+			if (relevant)
+				return NULL;
+			relevant = commit;
+		}
+	}
+	return relevant;
+}
+
+/*
  * The goal is to get REV_TREE_NEW as the result only if the
  * diff consists of all '+' (and no other changes), REV_TREE_OLD
  * if the whole diff is removal of old data, and otherwise
@@ -430,10 +504,125 @@ static int rev_same_tree_as_empty(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
 	return retval >= 0 && (tree_difference == REV_TREE_SAME);
 }
 
+struct treesame_state {
+	unsigned int nparents;
+	unsigned char treesame[FLEX_ARRAY];
+};
+
+static struct treesame_state *initialise_treesame(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	unsigned n = commit_list_count(commit->parents);
+	struct treesame_state *st = xcalloc(1, sizeof(*st) + n);
+	st->nparents = n;
+	add_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object, st);
+	return st;
+}
+
+/*
+ * Must be called immediately after removing the nth_parent from a commit's
+ * parent list, if we are maintaining the per-parent treesame[] decoration.
+ * This does not recalculate the master TREESAME flag - update_treesame()
+ * should be called to update it after a sequence of treesame[] modifications
+ * that may have affected it.
+ */
+static int compact_treesame(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit, unsigned nth_parent)
+{
+	struct treesame_state *st;
+	int old_same;
+
+	if (!commit->parents) {
+		/*
+		 * Have just removed the only parent from a non-merge.
+		 * Different handling, as we lack decoration.
+		 */
+		if (nth_parent != 0)
+			die("compact_treesame %u", nth_parent);
+		old_same = !!(commit->object.flags & TREESAME);
+		if (rev_same_tree_as_empty(revs, commit))
+			commit->object.flags |= TREESAME;
+		else
+			commit->object.flags &= ~TREESAME;
+		return old_same;
+	}
+
+	st = lookup_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object);
+	if (!st || nth_parent >= st->nparents)
+		die("compact_treesame %u", nth_parent);
+
+	old_same = st->treesame[nth_parent];
+	memmove(st->treesame + nth_parent,
+		st->treesame + nth_parent + 1,
+		st->nparents - nth_parent - 1);
+
+	/*
+	 * If we've just become a non-merge commit, update TREESAME
+	 * immediately, and remove the no-longer-needed decoration.
+	 * If still a merge, defer update until update_treesame().
+	 */
+	if (--st->nparents == 1) {
+		if (commit->parents->next)
+			die("compact_treesame parents mismatch");
+		if (st->treesame[0] && revs->dense)
+			commit->object.flags |= TREESAME;
+		else
+			commit->object.flags &= ~TREESAME;
+		free(add_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object, NULL));
+	}
+
+	return old_same;
+}
+
+static unsigned update_treesame(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	if (commit->parents && commit->parents->next) {
+		unsigned n;
+		struct treesame_state *st;
+		struct commit_list *p;
+		unsigned relevant_parents;
+		unsigned relevant_change, irrelevant_change;
+
+		st = lookup_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object);
+		if (!st)
+			die("update_treesame %s", sha1_to_hex(commit->object.sha1));
+		relevant_parents = 0;
+		relevant_change = irrelevant_change = 0;
+		for (p = commit->parents, n = 0; p; n++, p = p->next) {
+			if (relevant_commit(p->item)) {
+				relevant_change |= !st->treesame[n];
+				relevant_parents++;
+			} else
+				irrelevant_change |= !st->treesame[n];
+		}
+		if (relevant_parents ? relevant_change : irrelevant_change)
+			commit->object.flags &= ~TREESAME;
+		else
+			commit->object.flags |= TREESAME;
+	}
+
+	return commit->object.flags & TREESAME;
+}
+
+static inline int limiting_can_increase_treesame(const struct rev_info *revs)
+{
+	/*
+	 * TREESAME is irrelevant unless prune && dense;
+	 * if simplify_history is set, we can't have a mixture of TREESAME and
+	 *    !TREESAME INTERESTING parents (and we don't have treesame[]
+	 *    decoration anyway);
+	 * if first_parent_only is set, then the TREESAME flag is locked
+	 *    against the first parent (and again we lack treesame[] decoration).
+	 */
+	return revs->prune && revs->dense &&
+	       !revs->simplify_history &&
+	       !revs->first_parent_only;
+}
+
 static void try_to_simplify_commit(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
 {
 	struct commit_list **pp, *parent;
-	int tree_changed = 0, tree_same = 0, nth_parent = 0;
+	struct treesame_state *ts = NULL;
+	int relevant_change = 0, irrelevant_change = 0;
+	int relevant_parents, nth_parent;
 
 	/*
 	 * If we don't do pruning, everything is interesting
@@ -457,33 +646,54 @@ static void try_to_simplify_commit(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
 	if (!revs->dense && !commit->parents->next)
 		return;
 
-	pp = &commit->parents;
-	while ((parent = *pp) != NULL) {
+	for (pp = &commit->parents, nth_parent = 0, relevant_parents = 0;
+	     (parent = *pp) != NULL;
+	     pp = &parent->next, nth_parent++) {
 		struct commit *p = parent->item;
+		if (relevant_commit(p))
+			relevant_parents++;
 
-		/*
-		 * Do not compare with later parents when we care only about
-		 * the first parent chain, in order to avoid derailing the
-		 * traversal to follow a side branch that brought everything
-		 * in the path we are limited to by the pathspec.
-		 */
-		if (revs->first_parent_only && nth_parent++)
-			break;
+		if (nth_parent == 1) {
+			/*
+			 * This our second loop iteration - so we now know
+			 * we're dealing with a merge.
+			 *
+			 * Do not compare with later parents when we care only about
+			 * the first parent chain, in order to avoid derailing the
+			 * traversal to follow a side branch that brought everything
+			 * in the path we are limited to by the pathspec.
+			 */
+			if (revs->first_parent_only)
+				break;
+			/*
+			 * If this will remain a potentially-simplifiable
+			 * merge, remember per-parent treesame if needed.
+			 * Initialise the array with the comparison from our
+			 * first iteration.
+			 */
+			if (revs->treesame.name &&
+			    !revs->simplify_history &&
+			    !(commit->object.flags & UNINTERESTING)) {
+				ts = initialise_treesame(revs, commit);
+				if (!(irrelevant_change || relevant_change))
+					ts->treesame[0] = 1;
+			}
+		}
 		if (parse_commit(p) < 0)
 			die("cannot simplify commit %s (because of %s)",
 			    sha1_to_hex(commit->object.sha1),
 			    sha1_to_hex(p->object.sha1));
 		switch (rev_compare_tree(revs, p, commit)) {
 		case REV_TREE_SAME:
-			tree_same = 1;
-			if (!revs->simplify_history || (p->object.flags & UNINTERESTING)) {
+			if (!revs->simplify_history || !relevant_commit(p)) {
 				/* Even if a merge with an uninteresting
 				 * side branch brought the entire change
 				 * we are interested in, we do not want
 				 * to lose the other branches of this
 				 * merge, so we just keep going.
 				 */
-				pp = &parent->next;
+				if (ts)
+					ts->treesame[nth_parent] = 1;
 				continue;
 			}
 			parent->next = NULL;
@@ -511,15 +721,27 @@ static void try_to_simplify_commit(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
 		/* fallthrough */
 		case REV_TREE_OLD:
 		case REV_TREE_DIFFERENT:
-			tree_changed = 1;
-			pp = &parent->next;
+			if (relevant_commit(p))
+				relevant_change = 1;
+			else
+				irrelevant_change = 1;
 			continue;
 		}
 		die("bad tree compare for commit %s", sha1_to_hex(commit->object.sha1));
 	}
-	if (tree_changed && !tree_same)
-		return;
-	commit->object.flags |= TREESAME;
+
+	/*
+	 * TREESAME is straightforward for single-parent commits. For merge
+	 * commits, it is most useful to define it so that "irrelevant"
+	 * parents cannot make us !TREESAME - if we have any relevant
+	 * parents, then we only consider TREESAMEness with respect to them,
+	 * allowing irrelevant merges from uninteresting branches to be
+	 * simplified away. Only if we have only irrelevant parents do we
+	 * base TREESAME on them. Note that this logic is replicated in
+	 * update_treesame, which should be kept in sync.
+	 */
+	if (relevant_parents ? !relevant_change : !irrelevant_change)
+		commit->object.flags |= TREESAME;
 }
 
 static void commit_list_insert_by_date_cached(struct commit *p, struct commit_list **head,
@@ -802,16 +1024,12 @@ static void limit_to_ancestry(struct commit_list *bottom, struct commit_list *li
  * to filter the result of "A..B" further to the ones that can actually
  * reach A.
  */
-static struct commit_list *collect_bottom_commits(struct rev_info *revs)
+static struct commit_list *collect_bottom_commits(struct commit_list *list)
 {
-	struct commit_list *bottom = NULL;
-	int i;
-	for (i = 0; i < revs->cmdline.nr; i++) {
-		struct rev_cmdline_entry *elem = &revs->cmdline.rev[i];
-		if ((elem->flags & UNINTERESTING) &&
-		    elem->item->type == OBJ_COMMIT)
-			commit_list_insert((struct commit *)elem->item, &bottom);
-	}
+	struct commit_list *elem, *bottom = NULL;
+	for (elem = list; elem; elem = elem->next)
+		if (elem->item->object.flags & BOTTOM)
+			commit_list_insert(elem->item, &bottom);
 	return bottom;
 }
 
@@ -842,7 +1060,7 @@ static int limit_list(struct rev_info *revs)
 	struct commit_list *bottom = NULL;
 
 	if (revs->ancestry_path) {
-		bottom = collect_bottom_commits(revs);
+		bottom = collect_bottom_commits(list);
 		if (!bottom)
 			die("--ancestry-path given but there are no bottom commits");
 	}
@@ -895,6 +1113,18 @@ static int limit_list(struct rev_info *revs)
 		free_commit_list(bottom);
 	}
 
+	/*
+	 * Check if any commits have become TREESAME by some of their parents
+	 * becoming UNINTERESTING.
+	 */
+	if (limiting_can_increase_treesame(revs))
+		for (list = newlist; list; list = list->next) {
+			struct commit *c = list->item;
+			if (c->object.flags & (UNINTERESTING | TREESAME))
+				continue;
+			update_treesame(revs, c);
+		}
+
 	revs->commits = newlist;
 	return 0;
 }
@@ -1014,7 +1244,7 @@ static int add_parents_only(struct rev_info *revs, const char *arg_, int flags)
 	const char *arg = arg_;
 
 	if (*arg == '^') {
-		flags ^= UNINTERESTING;
+		flags ^= UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM;
 		arg++;
 	}
 	if (get_sha1_committish(arg, sha1))
@@ -1106,8 +1336,8 @@ static void prepare_show_merge(struct rev_info *revs)
 	add_pending_object(revs, &head->object, "HEAD");
 	add_pending_object(revs, &other->object, "MERGE_HEAD");
 	bases = get_merge_bases(head, other, 1);
-	add_rev_cmdline_list(revs, bases, REV_CMD_MERGE_BASE, UNINTERESTING);
-	add_pending_commit_list(revs, bases, UNINTERESTING);
+	add_rev_cmdline_list(revs, bases, REV_CMD_MERGE_BASE, UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM);
+	add_pending_commit_list(revs, bases, UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM);
 	free_commit_list(bases);
 	head->object.flags |= SYMMETRIC_LEFT;
 
@@ -1143,13 +1373,15 @@ int handle_revision_arg(const char *arg_, struct rev_info *revs, int flags, unsi
 	int cant_be_filename = revarg_opt & REVARG_CANNOT_BE_FILENAME;
 	unsigned get_sha1_flags = 0;
 
+	flags = flags & UNINTERESTING ? flags | BOTTOM : flags & ~BOTTOM;
+
 	dotdot = strstr(arg, "..");
 	if (dotdot) {
 		unsigned char from_sha1[20];
 		const char *next = dotdot + 2;
 		const char *this = arg;
 		int symmetric = *next == '.';
-		unsigned int flags_exclude = flags ^ UNINTERESTING;
+		unsigned int flags_exclude = flags ^ (UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM);
 		static const char head_by_default[] = "HEAD";
 		unsigned int a_flags;
 
@@ -1225,13 +1457,13 @@ int handle_revision_arg(const char *arg_, struct rev_info *revs, int flags, unsi
 	dotdot = strstr(arg, "^!");
 	if (dotdot && !dotdot[2]) {
 		*dotdot = 0;
-		if (!add_parents_only(revs, arg, flags ^ UNINTERESTING))
+		if (!add_parents_only(revs, arg, flags ^ (UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM)))
 			*dotdot = '^';
 	}
 
 	local_flags = 0;
 	if (*arg == '^') {
-		local_flags = UNINTERESTING;
+		local_flags = UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM;
 		arg++;
 	}
 
@@ -1708,7 +1940,7 @@ static int handle_revision_pseudo_opt(const char *submodule,
 		handle_refs(submodule, revs, *flags, for_each_branch_ref_submodule);
 	} else if (!strcmp(arg, "--bisect")) {
 		handle_refs(submodule, revs, *flags, for_each_bad_bisect_ref);
-		handle_refs(submodule, revs, *flags ^ UNINTERESTING, for_each_good_bisect_ref);
+		handle_refs(submodule, revs, *flags ^ (UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM), for_each_good_bisect_ref);
 		revs->bisect = 1;
 	} else if (!strcmp(arg, "--tags")) {
 		handle_refs(submodule, revs, *flags, for_each_tag_ref_submodule);
@@ -1734,7 +1966,7 @@ static int handle_revision_pseudo_opt(const char *submodule,
 	} else if (!strcmp(arg, "--reflog")) {
 		handle_reflog(revs, *flags);
 	} else if (!strcmp(arg, "--not")) {
-		*flags ^= UNINTERESTING;
+		*flags ^= UNINTERESTING | BOTTOM;
 	} else if (!strcmp(arg, "--no-walk")) {
 		revs->no_walk = REVISION_WALK_NO_WALK_SORTED;
 	} else if (!prefixcmp(arg, "--no-walk=")) {
@@ -1954,28 +2186,32 @@ static void add_child(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *parent, struct commi
 	l->next = add_decoration(&revs->children, &parent->object, l);
 }
 
-static int remove_duplicate_parents(struct commit *commit)
+static int remove_duplicate_parents(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
 {
+	struct treesame_state *ts = lookup_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object);
 	struct commit_list **pp, *p;
 	int surviving_parents;
 
 	/* Examine existing parents while marking ones we have seen... */
 	pp = &commit->parents;
+	surviving_parents = 0;
 	while ((p = *pp) != NULL) {
 		struct commit *parent = p->item;
 		if (parent->object.flags & TMP_MARK) {
 			*pp = p->next;
+			if (ts)
+				compact_treesame(revs, commit, surviving_parents);
 			continue;
 		}
 		parent->object.flags |= TMP_MARK;
+		surviving_parents++;
 		pp = &p->next;
 	}
-	/* count them while clearing the temporary mark */
-	surviving_parents = 0;
+	/* clear the temporary mark */
 	for (p = commit->parents; p; p = p->next) {
 		p->item->object.flags &= ~TMP_MARK;
-		surviving_parents++;
 	}
+	/* no update_treesame() - removing duplicates can't affect TREESAME */
 	return surviving_parents;
 }
 
@@ -1995,9 +2231,157 @@ static struct merge_simplify_state *locate_simplify_state(struct rev_info *revs,
 	return st;
 }
 
+static int mark_redundant_parents(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	struct commit_list *h = reduce_heads(commit->parents);
+	int i = 0, marked = 0;
+	struct commit_list *po, *pn;
+
+	/* Want these for sanity-checking only */
+	int orig_cnt = commit_list_count(commit->parents);
+	int cnt = commit_list_count(h);
+
+	/*
+	 * Not ready to remove items yet, just mark them for now, based
+	 * on the output of reduce_heads(). reduce_heads outputs the reduced
+	 * set in its original order, so this isn't too hard.
+	 */
+	po = commit->parents;
+	pn = h;
+	while (po) {
+		if (pn && po->item == pn->item) {
+			pn = pn->next;
+			i++;
+		} else {
+			po->item->object.flags |= TMP_MARK;
+			marked++;
+		}
+		po=po->next;
+	}
+
+	if (i != cnt || cnt+marked != orig_cnt)
+		die("mark_redundant_parents %d %d %d %d", orig_cnt, cnt, i, marked);
+
+	free_commit_list(h);
+
+	return marked;
+}
+
+static int mark_treesame_root_parents(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	struct commit_list *p;
+	int marked = 0;
+
+	for (p = commit->parents; p; p = p->next) {
+		struct commit *parent = p->item;
+		if (!parent->parents && (parent->object.flags & TREESAME)) {
+			parent->object.flags |= TMP_MARK;
+			marked++;
+		}
+	}
+
+	return marked;
+}
+
+/*
+ * Awkward naming - this means one parent we are TREESAME to.
+ * cf mark_treesame_root_parents: root parents that are TREESAME (to an
+ * empty tree). Better name suggestions?
+ */
+static int leave_one_treesame_to_parent(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	struct treesame_state *ts = lookup_decoration(&revs->treesame, &commit->object);
+	struct commit *unmarked = NULL, *marked = NULL;
+	struct commit_list *p;
+	unsigned n;
+
+	for (p = commit->parents, n = 0; p; p = p->next, n++) {
+		if (ts->treesame[n]) {
+			if (p->item->object.flags & TMP_MARK) {
+				if (!marked)
+					marked = p->item;
+			} else {
+				if (!unmarked) {
+					unmarked = p->item;
+					break;
+				}
+			}
+		}
+	}
+
+	/*
+	 * If we are TREESAME to a marked-for-deletion parent, but not to any
+	 * unmarked parents, unmark the first TREESAME parent. This is the
+	 * parent that the default simplify_history==1 scan would have followed,
+	 * and it doesn't make sense to omit that path when asking for a
+	 * simplified full history. Retaining it improves the chances of
+	 * understanding odd missed merges that took an old version of a file.
+	 *
+	 * Example:
+	 *
+	 *   I--------*X       A modified the file, but mainline merge X used
+	 *    \       /        "-s ours", so took the version from I. X is
+	 *     `-*A--'         TREESAME to I and !TREESAME to A.
+	 *
+	 * Default log from X would produce "I". Without this check,
+	 * --full-history --simplify-merges would produce "I-A-X", showing
+	 * the merge commit X and that it changed A, but not making clear that
+	 * it had just taken the I version. With this check, the topology above
+	 * is retained.
+	 *
+	 * Note that it is possible that the simplification chooses a different
+	 * TREESAME parent from the default, in which case this test doesn't
+	 * activate, and we _do_ drop the default parent. Example:
+	 *
+	 *   I------X         A modified the file, but it was reverted in B,
+	 *    \    /          meaning mainline merge X is TREESAME to both
+	 *    *A-*B           parents.
+	 *
+	 * Default log would produce "I" by following the first parent;
+	 * --full-history --simplify-merges will produce "I-A-B". But this is a
+	 * reasonable result - it presents a logical full history leading from
+	 * I to X, and X is not an important merge.
+	 */
+	if (!unmarked && marked) {
+		marked->object.flags &= ~TMP_MARK;
+		return 1;
+	}
+
+	return 0;
+}
+
+static int remove_marked_parents(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit)
+{
+	struct commit_list **pp, *p;
+	int nth_parent, removed = 0;
+
+	pp = &commit->parents;
+	nth_parent = 0;
+	while ((p = *pp) != NULL) {
+		struct commit *parent = p->item;
+		if (parent->object.flags & TMP_MARK) {
+			parent->object.flags &= ~TMP_MARK;
+			*pp = p->next;
+			free(p);
+			removed++;
+			compact_treesame(revs, commit, nth_parent);
+			continue;
+		}
+		pp = &p->next;
+		nth_parent++;
+	}
+
+	/* Removing parents can only increase TREESAMEness */
+	if (removed && !(commit->object.flags & TREESAME))
+		update_treesame(revs, commit);
+
+	return nth_parent;
+}
+
 static struct commit_list **simplify_one(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit, struct commit_list **tail)
 {
 	struct commit_list *p;
+	struct commit *parent;
 	struct merge_simplify_state *st, *pst;
 	int cnt;
 
@@ -2039,7 +2423,9 @@ static struct commit_list **simplify_one(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *c
 	}
 
 	/*
-	 * Rewrite our list of parents.
+	 * Rewrite our list of parents. Note that this cannot
+	 * affect our TREESAME flags in any way - a commit is
+	 * always TREESAME to its simplification.
 	 */
 	for (p = commit->parents; p; p = p->next) {
 		pst = locate_simplify_state(revs, p->item);
@@ -2051,43 +2437,53 @@ static struct commit_list **simplify_one(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *c
 	if (revs->first_parent_only)
 		cnt = 1;
 	else
-		cnt = remove_duplicate_parents(commit);
+		cnt = remove_duplicate_parents(revs, commit);
 
 	/*
 	 * It is possible that we are a merge and one side branch
 	 * does not have any commit that touches the given paths;
-	 * in such a case, the immediate parents will be rewritten
-	 * to different commits.
+	 * in such a case, the immediate parent from that branch
+	 * will be rewritten to be the merge base.
 	 *
 	 *      o----X		X: the commit we are looking at;
 	 *     /    /		o: a commit that touches the paths;
 	 * ---o----'
 	 *
-	 * Further reduce the parents by removing redundant parents.
+	 * Further, a merge of an independent branch that doesn't
+	 * touch the path will reduce to a treesame root parent:
+	 *
+	 *  ----o----X		X: the commit we are looking at;
+	 *          /		o: a commit that touches the paths;
+	 *         r		r: a root commit not touching the paths
+	 *
+	 * Detect and simplify both cases.
 	 */
 	if (1 < cnt) {
-		struct commit_list *h = reduce_heads(commit->parents);
-		cnt = commit_list_count(h);
-		free_commit_list(commit->parents);
-		commit->parents = h;
+		int marked = mark_redundant_parents(revs, commit);
+		marked += mark_treesame_root_parents(revs, commit);
+		if (marked)
+			marked -= leave_one_treesame_to_parent(revs, commit);
+		if (marked)
+			cnt = remove_marked_parents(revs, commit);
 	}
 
 	/*
 	 * A commit simplifies to itself if it is a root, if it is
 	 * UNINTERESTING, if it touches the given paths, or if it is a
-	 * merge and its parents simplifies to more than one commits
+	 * merge and its parents don't simplify to one relevant commit
 	 * (the first two cases are already handled at the beginning of
 	 * this function).
 	 *
-	 * Otherwise, it simplifies to what its sole parent simplifies to.
+	 * Otherwise, it simplifies to what its sole relevant parent
+	 * simplifies to.
 	 */
 	if (!cnt ||
 	    (commit->object.flags & UNINTERESTING) ||
 	    !(commit->object.flags & TREESAME) ||
-	    (1 < cnt))
+	    (parent = one_relevant_parent(revs, commit->parents)) == NULL)
 		st->simplified = commit;
 	else {
-		pst = locate_simplify_state(revs, commit->parents->item);
+		pst = locate_simplify_state(revs, parent);
 		st->simplified = pst->simplified;
 	}
 	return tail;
@@ -2183,6 +2579,11 @@ int prepare_revision_walk(struct rev_info *revs)
 	if (!revs->leak_pending)
 		free(list);
 
+	/* Signal whether we need per-parent treesame decoration */
+	if (revs->simplify_merges ||
+	    (revs->limited && limiting_can_increase_treesame(revs)))
+		revs->treesame.name = "treesame";
+
 	if (revs->no_walk != REVISION_WALK_NO_WALK_UNSORTED)
 		commit_list_sort_by_date(&revs->commits);
 	if (revs->no_walk)
@@ -2210,15 +2611,15 @@ static enum rewrite_result rewrite_one(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit **pp
 		if (!revs->limited)
 			if (add_parents_to_list(revs, p, &revs->commits, &cache) < 0)
 				return rewrite_one_error;
-		if (p->parents && p->parents->next)
-			return rewrite_one_ok;
 		if (p->object.flags & UNINTERESTING)
 			return rewrite_one_ok;
 		if (!(p->object.flags & TREESAME))
 			return rewrite_one_ok;
 		if (!p->parents)
 			return rewrite_one_noparents;
-		*pp = p->parents->item;
+		if ((p = one_relevant_parent(revs, p->parents)) == NULL)
+			return rewrite_one_ok;
+		*pp = p;
 	}
 }
 
@@ -2239,7 +2640,7 @@ int rewrite_parents(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commit,
 		}
 		pp = &parent->next;
 	}
-	remove_duplicate_parents(commit);
+	remove_duplicate_parents(revs, commit);
 	return 0;
 }
 
@@ -2363,10 +2764,7 @@ enum commit_action get_commit_action(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commi
 	if (revs->min_age != -1 && (commit->date > revs->min_age))
 		return commit_ignore;
 	if (revs->min_parents || (revs->max_parents >= 0)) {
-		int n = 0;
-		struct commit_list *p;
-		for (p = commit->parents; p; p = p->next)
-			n++;
+		int n = commit_list_count(commit->parents);
 		if ((n < revs->min_parents) ||
 		    ((revs->max_parents >= 0) && (n > revs->max_parents)))
 			return commit_ignore;
@@ -2376,12 +2774,23 @@ enum commit_action get_commit_action(struct rev_info *revs, struct commit *commi
 	if (revs->prune && revs->dense) {
 		/* Commit without changes? */
 		if (commit->object.flags & TREESAME) {
+			int n;
+			struct commit_list *p;
 			/* drop merges unless we want parenthood */
 			if (!want_ancestry(revs))
 				return commit_ignore;
-			/* non-merge - always ignore it */
-			if (!commit->parents || !commit->parents->next)
-				return commit_ignore;
+			/*
+			 * If we want ancestry, then need to keep any merges
+			 * between relevant commits to tie together topology.
+			 * For consistency with TREESAME and simplification
+			 * use "relevant" here rather than just INTERESTING,
+			 * to treat bottom commit(s) as part of the topology.
+			 */
+			for (n = 0, p = commit->parents; p; p = p->next)
+				if (relevant_commit(p->item))
+					if (++n >= 2)
+						return commit_show;
+			return commit_ignore;
 		}
 	}
 	return commit_show;
diff --git a/revision.h b/revision.h
index a313a1340..24547b59f 100644
--- a/revision.h
+++ b/revision.h
@@ -15,7 +15,8 @@
 #define ADDED		(1u<<7)	/* Parents already parsed and added? */
 #define SYMMETRIC_LEFT	(1u<<8)
 #define PATCHSAME	(1u<<9)
-#define ALL_REV_FLAGS	((1u<<10)-1)
+#define BOTTOM		(1u<<10)
+#define ALL_REV_FLAGS	((1u<<11)-1)
 
 #define DECORATE_SHORT_REFS	1
 #define DECORATE_FULL_REFS	2
@@ -169,6 +170,7 @@ struct rev_info {
 	struct reflog_walk_info *reflog_info;
 	struct decoration children;
 	struct decoration merge_simplification;
+	struct decoration treesame;
 
 	/* notes-specific options: which refs to show */
 	struct display_notes_opt notes_opt;
diff --git a/t/t6012-rev-list-simplify.sh b/t/t6012-rev-list-simplify.sh
index dd6dc844e..57ce2395d 100755
--- a/t/t6012-rev-list-simplify.sh
+++ b/t/t6012-rev-list-simplify.sh
@@ -14,21 +14,24 @@ unnote () {
 
 test_expect_success setup '
 	echo "Hi there" >file &&
-	git add file &&
-	test_tick && git commit -m "Initial file" &&
+	echo "initial" >lost &&
+	git add file lost &&
+	test_tick && git commit -m "Initial file and lost" &&
 	note A &&
 
 	git branch other-branch &&
 
 	echo "Hello" >file &&
-	git add file &&
-	test_tick && git commit -m "Modified file" &&
+	echo "second" >lost &&
+	git add file lost &&
+	test_tick && git commit -m "Modified file and lost" &&
 	note B &&
 
 	git checkout other-branch &&
 
 	echo "Hello" >file &&
-	git add file &&
+	>lost &&
+	git add file lost &&
 	test_tick && git commit -m "Modified the file identically" &&
 	note C &&
 
@@ -37,7 +40,9 @@ test_expect_success setup '
 	test_tick && git commit -m "Add another file" &&
 	note D &&
 
-	test_tick && git merge -m "merge" master &&
+	test_tick &&
+	test_must_fail git merge -m "merge" master &&
+	>lost && git commit -a -m "merge" &&
 	note E &&
 
 	echo "Yet another" >elif &&
@@ -105,9 +110,21 @@ check_result 'L K J I H G F E D C B A' --full-history
 check_result 'K I H E C B A' --full-history -- file
 check_result 'K I H E C B A' --full-history --topo-order -- file
 check_result 'K I H E C B A' --full-history --date-order -- file
-check_outcome failure 'I E C B A' --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'I E C B A' --simplify-merges -- file
 check_result 'I B A' -- file
 check_result 'I B A' --topo-order -- file
 check_result 'H' --first-parent -- another-file
 
+check_result 'E C B A' --full-history E -- lost
+test_expect_success 'full history simplification without parent' '
+	printf "%s\n" E C B A >expect &&
+	git log --pretty="$FMT" --full-history E -- lost |
+	unnote >actual &&
+	sed -e "s/^.*	\([^ ]*\) .*/\1/" >check <actual &&
+	test_cmp expect check || {
+		cat actual
+		false
+	}
+'
+
 test_done
diff --git a/t/t6019-rev-list-ancestry-path.sh b/t/t6019-rev-list-ancestry-path.sh
index dd5b0e55d..dabebaee0 100755
--- a/t/t6019-rev-list-ancestry-path.sh
+++ b/t/t6019-rev-list-ancestry-path.sh
@@ -16,6 +16,10 @@ test_description='--ancestry-path'
 #
 #  F...I                 == F G H I
 #  --ancestry-path F...I == F H I
+#
+#  G..M -- G.t                 == [nothing - was dropped in "-s ours" merge L]
+#  --ancestry-path G..M -- G.t == L
+#  --ancestry-path --simplify-merges G^..M -- G.t == G L
 
 . ./test-lib.sh
 
@@ -89,6 +93,29 @@ test_expect_success 'rev-list --ancestry-path F...I' '
 	test_cmp expect actual
 '
 
+# G.t is dropped in an "-s ours" merge
+test_expect_success 'rev-list G..M -- G.t' '
+	>expect &&
+	git rev-list --format=%s G..M -- G.t |
+	sed -e "/^commit /d" >actual &&
+	test_cmp expect actual
+'
+
+test_expect_success 'rev-list --ancestry-path G..M -- G.t' '
+	echo L >expect &&
+	git rev-list --ancestry-path --format=%s G..M -- G.t |
+	sed -e "/^commit /d" >actual &&
+	test_cmp expect actual
+'
+
+test_expect_success 'rev-list --ancestry-path --simplify-merges G^..M -- G.t' '
+	for c in G L; do echo $c; done >expect &&
+	git rev-list --ancestry-path --simplify-merges --format=%s G^..M -- G.t |
+	sed -e "/^commit /d" |
+	sort >actual &&
+	test_cmp expect actual
+'
+
 #   b---bc
 #  / \ /
 # a   X
diff --git a/t/t6111-rev-list-treesame.sh b/t/t6111-rev-list-treesame.sh
new file mode 100755
index 000000000..88b84dfa7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/t/t6111-rev-list-treesame.sh
@@ -0,0 +1,196 @@
+#!/bin/sh
+#
+#        ,---E--.   *H----------.             * marks !TREESAME parent paths
+#       /        \ /             \*
+# *A--*B---D--*F-*G---------K-*L-*M
+#   \     /*       \       /
+#    `-C-'          `-*I-*J
+#
+# A creates "file", B and F change it.
+# Odd merge G takes the old version from B.
+# I changes it, but J reverts it, so K is TREESAME to both parents.
+# H and L both change "file", and M merges those changes.
+
+test_description='TREESAME and limiting'
+
+. ./test-lib.sh
+
+note () {
+	git tag "$1"
+}
+
+unnote () {
+	git name-rev --tags --stdin | sed -e "s|$_x40 (tags/\([^)]*\))\([ 	]\)|\1\2|g"
+}
+
+test_expect_success setup '
+	test_commit "Initial file" file "Hi there" A &&
+	git branch other-branch &&
+
+	test_commit "file=Hello" file "Hello" B &&
+	git branch third-branch &&
+
+	git checkout other-branch &&
+	test_commit "Added other" other "Hello" C &&
+
+	git checkout master &&
+	test_merge D other-branch &&
+
+	git checkout third-branch &&
+	test_commit "Third file" third "Nothing" E &&
+
+	git checkout master &&
+	test_commit "file=Blah" file "Blah" F &&
+
+	test_tick && git merge --no-commit third-branch &&
+	git checkout third-branch file &&
+	git commit &&
+	note G &&
+	git branch fiddler-branch &&
+
+	git checkout -b part2-branch &&
+	test_commit "file=Part 2" file "Part 2" H &&
+
+	git checkout fiddler-branch &&
+	test_commit "Bad commit" file "Silly" I &&
+
+	test_tick && git revert I && note J &&
+
+	git checkout master &&
+	test_tick && git merge --no-ff fiddler-branch &&
+	note K
+
+	test_commit "file=Part 1" file "Part 1" L &&
+
+	test_tick && test_must_fail git merge part2-branch &&
+	test_commit M file "Parts 1+2"
+'
+
+check_outcome () {
+	outcome=$1
+	shift
+
+	case "$1" in
+	*"("*)
+		FMT="%P	%H | %s"
+		munge_actual="
+			s/^\([^	]*\)	\([^ ]*\) .*/(\1)\2/
+			s/ //g
+			s/()//
+		"
+		;;
+	*)
+		FMT="%H | %s"
+		munge_actual="s/^\([^ ]*\) .*/\1/"
+		;;
+	esac &&
+	printf "%s\n" $1 >expect &&
+	shift
+
+	param="$*" &&
+	test_expect_$outcome "log $param" '
+		git log --format="$FMT" $param |
+		unnote >actual &&
+		sed -e "$munge_actual" <actual >check &&
+		test_cmp expect check || {
+			cat actual
+			false
+		}
+	'
+}
+
+check_result () {
+	check_outcome success "$@"
+}
+
+# Odd merge G drops a change in F. Important that G is listed in all
+# except the most basic list. Achieving this means normal merge D will also be
+# shown in normal full-history, as we can't distinguish unless we do a
+# simplification pass. After simplification, D is dropped but G remains.
+# Also, merge simplification of G should not drop the parent B that the default
+# simple history follows.
+check_result 'M L K J I H G F E D C B A'
+check_result '(LH)M (K)L (GJ)K (I)J (G)I (G)H (FE)G (D)F (B)E (BC)D (A)C (A)B A'
+check_result 'M H L K J I G E F D C B A' --topo-order
+check_result 'M L H B A' -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (B)L (B)H (A)B A' --parents -- file
+check_result 'M L J I H G F D B A' --full-history -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (K)L (GJ)K (I)J (G)I (G)H (FB)G (D)F (BA)D (A)B A' --full-history --parents -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (G)H (J)L (I)J (G)I (FB)G (B)F (A)B A' --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'M L K G F D B A' --first-parent
+check_result 'M L G F B A' --first-parent -- file
+
+# Check that odd merge G remains shown when F is the bottom.
+check_result 'M L K J I H G E' F..M
+check_result 'M H L K J I G E' F..M --topo-order
+check_result 'M L H' F..M -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (B)L (B)H' --parents F..M -- file
+check_result 'M L J I H G' F..M --full-history -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (K)L (GJ)K (I)J (G)I (G)H (FB)G' F..M --full-history --parents -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (G)H (J)L (I)J (G)I (FB)G' F..M --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'M L K J I H G' F..M --ancestry-path
+check_result 'M L J I H G' F..M --ancestry-path -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (K)L (GJ)K (I)J (G)I (G)H (FE)G' F..M --ancestry-path --parents -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (G)H (J)L (I)J (G)I (FE)G' F..M --ancestry-path --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'M L K G' F..M --first-parent
+check_result 'M L G' F..M --first-parent -- file
+
+# Note that G is pruned when E is the bottom, even if it's the same commit list
+# If we want history since E, then we're quite happy to ignore G that took E.
+check_result 'M L K J I H G' E..M --ancestry-path
+check_result 'M L J I H' E..M --ancestry-path -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (K)L (EJ)K (I)J (E)I (E)H' E..M --ancestry-path --parents -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (E)H (J)L (I)J (E)I' E..M --ancestry-path --simplify-merges -- file
+
+# Should still be able to ignore I-J branch in simple log, despite limiting
+# to G.
+check_result 'M L K J I H' G..M
+check_result 'M H L K J I' G..M --topo-order
+check_result 'M L H' G..M -- file
+check_result '(LH)M (G)L (G)H' G..M --parents -- file
+check_result 'M L J I H' G..M --full-history -- file
+check_result 'M L K J I H' G..M --full-history --parents -- file
+check_result 'M H L J I' G..M --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'M L K J I H' G..M --ancestry-path
+check_result 'M L J I H' G..M --ancestry-path -- file
+check_result 'M L K J I H' G..M --ancestry-path --parents -- file
+check_result 'M H L J I' G..M --ancestry-path --simplify-merges -- file
+
+# B..F should be able to simplify the merge D from irrelevant side branch C.
+# Default log should also be free to follow B-D, and ignore C.
+# But --full-history shouldn't drop D on its own - without simplification,
+# we can't decide if the merge from INTERESTING commit C was sensible.
+check_result 'F D C' B..F
+check_result 'F' B..F -- file
+check_result '(B)F' B..F --parents -- file
+check_result 'F D' B..F --full-history -- file
+check_result '(D)F (BA)D' B..F --full-history --parents -- file
+check_result '(B)F' B..F --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'F D' B..F --ancestry-path
+check_result 'F' B..F --ancestry-path -- file
+check_result 'F' B..F --ancestry-path --parents -- file
+check_result 'F' B..F --ancestry-path --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'F D' B..F --first-parent
+check_result 'F' B..F --first-parent -- file
+
+# E...F should be equivalent to E F ^B, and be able to drop D as above.
+check_result 'F' E F ^B -- file # includes D
+check_result 'F' E...F -- file # includes D
+
+# Any sort of full history of C..F should show D, as it's the connection to C,
+# and it differs from it.
+check_result 'F D B' C..F
+check_result 'F B' C..F -- file
+check_result '(B)F (A)B' C..F --parents -- file
+check_result 'F D B' C..F --full-history -- file
+check_result '(D)F (BC)D (A)B' C..F --full-history --parents -- file
+check_result '(D)F (BC)D (A)B' C..F --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'F D' C..F --ancestry-path
+check_result 'F D' C..F --ancestry-path -- file
+check_result 'F D' C..F --ancestry-path --parents -- file
+check_result 'F D' C..F --ancestry-path --simplify-merges -- file
+check_result 'F D B' C..F --first-parent
+check_result 'F B' C..F --first-parent -- file
+
+
+test_done